I'm a fellow Ohioian, but I'm only 14 so..
As interpited, if you are asking for a good street bike there are a few options. KTM makes a long line of excellent Dual sport bikes street legal, and supermotos. But alot of times KTM can be a bit pricer than most. Suzuki's DRZ line is also excellent, as said above the 400s are fairly tame legal dual sport bikes that you can have some fun with. Yamaha makes a WR-R line that is also street legal with some pretty gnarley options
WR250R WR450R. Kawasaki makes KLRs that are pretty cool too. Lastly Honda makes the ZR650L and the CRF230L. All these are good choices, anything else probably won't be. I can also post up some of their pics if you'd like me to
Now with this said, you need to have a motorcycle endorsement on your licenes and motorcycle insurance for anything over 49cc. The classes are easy, cheap and very intreasting. As far as the insurance goes, it can get pretty expensive but it'll still be cheaper than a car