I have a remington 870 express right now. If I get another 870 it will be the super magnum. As for the Benelli I don't know if the supernova is worth the extra money. I love the gun but it doesnt have a 3 1/2" chamber it only shoots 3" shells. I hunt geese so a 3 1/2" chamber is a must. The gun I am going to get is going to be my all pourpose shotgun. This means it has to be durable and comfortable. I am going to buy a full choke and then once I get the money I will also buy a slug barrel to hunt deer with. I was loving the idea and looks of the remington 887 but the reviews are so mixed I am not going to test it. The 870 and the Nova has had nothing but good reviews. I would like to know which you guys prefer and why? What are the good and bad or each gun.... Thanks for reading my novel!